Tuesday, September 12, 2017

Mrs. Dalloway and Doctors

In Mrs. Dalloway, Woolf has two doctor characters that are related to two characters with different types of problems: Dr. Holmes with Septimus for his mental issues, and an unnamed doctor for Clarissa and her illness.  Both Doctors are put in a negative light with the way they try to cure those problems.
In Doctor Holmes case, he seems to drive Septimus even more crazy and eventually becomes the source of a lot of Septimus's negative attitudes. At first, however, Dr. Holmes even denies that there is a problem with Septimus. He claims that all Septimus has to do is be more manly and all his issues will go away, a view more widely accepted by the British public than the actual condition of shell shock (or ptsd) itself was. Eventually Holmes's bad treatment of Septimus results in Septimus's condition worsening and Septimus hating Holmes. Septimus's hatred for Holmes spreads to the British public because of the shared views of the public and Holmes. At this point in the story most readers probably view Holmes as at the very least a bad doctor if not just a bad person, and this is Woolf's commentary on most doctors. However she also uses Holmes as a representation of British society at the time and uses him to critique its views of manliness and the war. This is most explicitly shown when Septimus finally kills himself. Septimus jumps out the window as Holmes comes barging into the room and Holmes yells "coward" expressing the views of the British public about the mental state of the veterans who were traumatized in the war. This seems especially cruel because of the circumstances: the mistreatment and neglect of Septimus by Holmes, and our knowledge of Septimus's thoughts due to Woolf's style of writing. This combination of mistreatment, neglect, cruelty, and ignorance all are commentaries on doctors at the time and British society as a whole.
In the case of Mrs. Dalloway's doctor we see that the treatment assigned to Clarissa is not necessarily the best or one that she agrees with. After her recovery from illness Clarissa is assigned the rest cure, something that she does not openly resent, but something she does make a small commentary on; she sort of makes fun of Richard for making her keep to the rest cure. Especially as the rest cure was something that Virginia Woolf herself was subjected to, I think this is commentary on the rest cure itself, similar to the yellow wallpaper (although not as extreme) in that she disagrees with it.
Finally in The Hours Virginia Woolf (or at least her character) is depicted as absolutely hating the rest cure. She claimed that it was time for them to get back to London and that she was the only one who could accurately judge her own mental state. She even had a large, public argument with her husband over releasing herself from the rest cure. All in all Virginia Woolf seems to have had a low opinion of the way British society and doctors respond to mental and physical illnesses, but that leaves us with the question: how much of her opinion was those peoples' fault?

7 comments:

  1. This blogpost relates perfectly to what we talked to in 5th hour today! The section where Woolf talks about Septimus's appointment with Bradshaw deviates from Woolf's overall writing style. The reason for this is that the passage seems to be narrated by Woolf herself. Virginia Woolf struggled with depression and was prescribed the rest cure so I believe that a lot what she saying about doctors is her personal opinion. I agree that these passages give great insight on doctors from that time period! Great blogpost!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think that Clarissa's opinion of doctors is really just an extension of how she feels about British society as a whole. She is made uncomfortable by Sir Bradshaw (she's clearly on Septimus' side) and that is a symbol for how she's uncomfortable trying to fit the mold provided to her by her culture.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Like Bella said, I think Clarissa's critique of doctors is an extent of her critique on 20th century British ideology. I find it interesting how the ideologies regarding mental health and gender intersect. Septimus, male, was prescribed (quite literally) football. In other words, to man up and quit scaring his wife. Clarissa, female, was prescribed the rest cure, a passive activity that shoved her away from society and involvement in it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think that Woolf's depiction of doctors and "cures" in the novel is a direct parallel to how British society during that time viewed mental illness and post war trauma. Mental illness was not thought of as a valid illness and the "rest cure" reinforced that idea. In the hours we can clearly see how depression and mental illness effected the three main characters, and in all time lines they seemed to not have resources or a way to get help which i thought was interesting.Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I mean Woolf clearly has issues with the doctors practicing at that time. By displaying how ignorant doctors were of PTSD, she also highlights the social "Mold" that men were supposed to fill. They were supposed to just man up, which is pretty hard to do if you have a mental condition. Interesting blogpost that explores the portrayal of doctors in Ms.Dalloway!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Doctors are generally highly respected members of society, so this critique of them does a good job of critiquing the society on a whole. It also revealed to me just how little knowledge about medical psychology there was in the early post-War era. Not only is PTSD not recognized, people think that complete rest is good, when in fact it gives you time to dwell on your condition, possibly worsening it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. It's true that Clarissa's doctor has recommended rest--and Richard sticks to this program very closely, to Clarissa's irritation--but I don't think his diagnosis is specifically related to "the rest cure" (which was used at the time to treat "nervous" or psychological disorders, and which Woolf herself was subjected to). It is a relevant example, though, since Septimus is definitely prescribed the rest cure by Bradshaw (whom Clarissa instinctively dislikes, and specifically imagines being treated by, further strengthening the connection).

    But since she's recovering from a life-threatening case of influenza (at a time where the flu indeed claimed many lives), her doctor advising rest is probably not a terrible idea.

    ReplyDelete