Despite the fact that both The Mezzanine by Nicholas Baker and Mrs. Dalloway by Virginia Woolf are primarily
internally focused they have very different styles and purposes. In The Mezzanine, Baker focuses mainly on his main character Howie's obsession with trivial things and everyday routine's and interactions going into what is sometimes comical analyzation about things like straws, conversations, and putting on socks. Where as Woolf's novel is more focused on the feelings and emotions of her characters as they come up and what they reveal about the characters' subconscious thoughts and their impact on the story. These differences in focus create hugely different tones.
While The Mezzanine does have some deeper insights into Howie's character, the majority of the novel is focused on Howie's fascination with trivial things like everyday objects, social interactions, and routine's. For example, on page 12, Howie describes "enjoying the slippage of the inner surface of the sock against the underside of your foot" while putting on your sock, a routine that most character's would ignore, but one that Howie with his infinite enthusiasm for the trivial puts a great deal of thought into. This brings out a very exuberant and positive tone that keeps the book engaging. Meanwhile in Mrs Dalloway, the point of view switches from character to character and focuses on much more "important" things like memories and reactions of characters rather than just blatant amazement at the technology of the world. This often results in judgement of minor characters (and major characters) and can bring out a much more conflicted, unhappy tone than Baker's. That is not to say Mrs Dalloway is a depressing book, it is just that it is engaging for different reasons than the Mezzanine and those reasons are not tone related.
I agree that Mrs Dalloway is a much less cheerful book than the Mezzanine. Especially in the case of Septimus and Lucrezia, the tone is often unhappy, or in Richard's case, annoyed (at Hugh). Septimus and Clarissa are the only characters who express similar amounts of exuberance to Howie, and it only happens once or twice, rather than being the tone of the entire novel.
ReplyDeleteI agree, the two works focus on completely different topics. I'd like to add that in general, the events and characters in Mrs. Dalloway are less normal- people like Septimus and scenes like the car montage are far more unusual than anything in The Mezzanine, and this also contributes to the difference in tone between the two novels.
ReplyDeleteI definitely think these two books are different. Like you mentioned, the tone and focus vastly contrast the two. But I think they do have one thing in common- both novels reflect the time period of the 20th century very well. Through Howie's descriptions of things such as the old milk cartons and the invention of the air-dryer, Baker paints a very good picture of what ones' typical life might look like if they had a 9-5 job in an urban setting. Mrs. Dalloway reflects bustling London at the time, and society's opinions towards things like mental illness, war, and homosexuality.
ReplyDeleteIt is also important to note that while Mrs.Dalloway is focused around Clarissa, there are switches in perspective. This contrasts the Mezzanine where you are only in the head of Howie. Sure the style generally is similar because you are getting the private thoughts of both the main characters - but Mrs.Dalloway is nothing like Mezzanine in that you get deeper thoughts reflecting things beneath the surface. When you delve into ideas that go beyond the appearance of something, you open yourself up to a much richer plot, one that can be somber or unhappy... Good post though!
ReplyDelete