At the very beginning of the novel, Albert Camus' The Stranger, the tone there are multiple ways to interpret the tone of the narrator. For example you could interpret the famous first lines of the novel, "Maman died today. Or yesterday maybe, I don't know." as a general detachment with emotions that he should or shouldn't be feeling. However sense there is no more evidence towards this conclusion at this point (it is the start of the novel after all) you may not wish to judge the main character so harshly and you could come up with other explanations. For example, at first when I read this segment I interpreted the tone as much more effected by the death of his mother and in shock/ in a daze because of his mother's death. This daze could explain why he was so disoriented and confused about certain details (like what day his mother had died), and could also explain why his tone was so flat and detached, like he hadn't quite processed the death yet.
However, for me, the tone becomes much more specific as the novel goes on and it becomes harder and harder to sympathize with Meursault as simply in a grief stricken daze, and it becomes more apparent that Meursault fits better with the first interpretation of the tone: detached and unsympathetic. This is especially true during the scenes where Meursault is being asked to give an emotional response to either his mother's death or his own crime. In one such scene, while the magistrate is trying to get Meursault to tell him why he shot the dead body, Meursault shows a complete lack of emotional response to something that had in the past made criminals "weep at the sight of such suffering."This means that Meursault at least does not show emotional responses like other people do, and at the very least marks him out as different with other people. Another one of these scenes is when Meursault's attorney is asking if he was upset because of his mother's deathin response to which Meursault said things "all normal people have wished their loved ones were dead" and he would "rather Maman hadn't died." These two parts of his response are very revealing about how the narrator reacts to things and show that Meursault is not nearly as sorry as most people would be if their mothers had just died. These two examples of a lack of emotions on Meursault's part towards the end of the story make it seem like maybe Meursault is more like "Monseur Anit-Christ" as the Magistrate calls him and less of a grief stricken person in shock after his mother's death.
In the end I think that Meursault's character is meant to be an emotionless one due to the continued occurrences of evidence pointing to that fact, however it is interesting that the beginning of the book is so much more ambiguous than the rest of it. So all that remains to be asked is: was that ambiguity intentional or just an coincidence?
Monday, October 30, 2017
Thursday, October 5, 2017
Gregor: Matter of Fact or Salty
In the Metamorphosis we see everything that happens in the story around Gregor, but only from his perspective. To figure out how Gregor feels about his family's treatment of him and how he feels about his situation the reader is mostly forced to interpret the monologue going on inside of Gregor's head.
The way he talks about his working situation can be interpreted in multiple ways. In terms of how he describes his working situation he lists off reasons for why he is the only one in his family that can work. The two interpretations of this are that either he is happy with his situation and is telling himself why he has to be the one to work, or that he is being sarcastic and thinks that they should be working despite their conditions. The way he reacts when his mother seems to have an asthma attack when she and his sister are moving furniture in his room makes it seem like he definitely recognizes that with her condition she probably shouldn't be working, and in his sister's cases he seems to want to provide for her and adopts a plan to send her off to a conservatory no matter the price. This two things make it seem like Gregor is fine with his situation and is just speaking in a matter of fact way to explain things to himself. However the way he talks about his father and the way his mom quickly picks up work while he is "incapacitated" make it seem more like maybe they are not in fact unable to work. This combined with the ambiguity of the tone could point to Gregor being more sarcastic and angry about his situation. This becomes more and more plausible as the story goes on and it is revealed that his family begins to care for him more and more badly and Gregor becomes angered. However, this could simply point to a gradual decay of composure on Gregor's part rather than a continued anger at his family. These two interpretations of Gregor's tone show a definite ambiguity in his monologues, but at least in terms of how Gregor talks about his sister it is definitely positive. He recognizes that almost all of what his sister does that effects him, at least in parts one and two, is for him, even some things that could be interpreted as acts of fear are seen by Gregor as good things done for him. This tone towards his sister is the deciding factor that points me towards thinking that Gregor is only speaking matter of factly not sarcastically.
The way he talks about his working situation can be interpreted in multiple ways. In terms of how he describes his working situation he lists off reasons for why he is the only one in his family that can work. The two interpretations of this are that either he is happy with his situation and is telling himself why he has to be the one to work, or that he is being sarcastic and thinks that they should be working despite their conditions. The way he reacts when his mother seems to have an asthma attack when she and his sister are moving furniture in his room makes it seem like he definitely recognizes that with her condition she probably shouldn't be working, and in his sister's cases he seems to want to provide for her and adopts a plan to send her off to a conservatory no matter the price. This two things make it seem like Gregor is fine with his situation and is just speaking in a matter of fact way to explain things to himself. However the way he talks about his father and the way his mom quickly picks up work while he is "incapacitated" make it seem more like maybe they are not in fact unable to work. This combined with the ambiguity of the tone could point to Gregor being more sarcastic and angry about his situation. This becomes more and more plausible as the story goes on and it is revealed that his family begins to care for him more and more badly and Gregor becomes angered. However, this could simply point to a gradual decay of composure on Gregor's part rather than a continued anger at his family. These two interpretations of Gregor's tone show a definite ambiguity in his monologues, but at least in terms of how Gregor talks about his sister it is definitely positive. He recognizes that almost all of what his sister does that effects him, at least in parts one and two, is for him, even some things that could be interpreted as acts of fear are seen by Gregor as good things done for him. This tone towards his sister is the deciding factor that points me towards thinking that Gregor is only speaking matter of factly not sarcastically.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)