Thursday, October 5, 2017

Gregor: Matter of Fact or Salty

In the Metamorphosis we see everything that happens in the story around Gregor, but only from his perspective.  To figure out how Gregor feels about his family's treatment of him and how he feels about his situation the reader is mostly forced to interpret the monologue going on inside of Gregor's head.
The way he talks about his working situation  can be interpreted in multiple ways. In terms of how he describes his working situation he lists off reasons for why he is the only one in his family that can work. The two interpretations of this are that either he is happy with his situation and is telling himself why he has to be the one to work, or that he is being sarcastic and thinks that they should be working despite their conditions. The way he reacts when his mother seems to have an asthma attack when she and his sister are moving furniture in his room makes it seem like he definitely recognizes that with her condition she probably shouldn't be working, and in his sister's cases he seems to want to provide for her and adopts a plan to send her off to a conservatory no matter the price. This two things make it seem like Gregor is fine with his situation and is just speaking in a matter of fact way to explain things to himself. However the way he talks about his father and the way his mom quickly picks up work while he is "incapacitated" make it seem more like maybe they are not in fact unable to work. This combined with the ambiguity of the tone could point to Gregor being more sarcastic and angry about his situation. This becomes more and more plausible as the story goes on and it is revealed that his family begins to care for him more and more badly and Gregor becomes angered. However, this could simply point to a gradual decay of composure on Gregor's part rather than a continued anger at his family. These two interpretations of Gregor's tone show a definite ambiguity in his monologues, but at least in terms of how Gregor talks about his sister it is definitely positive. He recognizes that almost all of what his sister does that effects him, at least in parts one and two, is for him, even some things that could be interpreted as acts of fear are seen by Gregor as good things done for him. This tone towards his sister is the deciding factor that points me towards thinking that Gregor is only speaking matter of factly not sarcastically.

7 comments:

  1. I agree that this ambiguity adds an interesting element to these scenes. Depending on Gregor's tone, the scenes have extremely different implications. I personally think that the different tones are meant to coexist: the ambiguity shows the deeper conflict that Gregor is feeling. Obviously it sucks to have your family despise you. But for some reason (societal pressures contributing to his spinelessness?) Gregor tries his hardest to pretend that he's cool with it. He doesn't want to lash out at his sister, so he tries to frame any resentment/sarcasm in his mind as positive. Sometimes he succeeds at deluding himself; sometimes he doesn't.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think that at the beginning Gregor definitely talks about his sister in a positive light. However, now I think he is starting to get mad at her. He gets annoyed at her when she starts moving all the furniture out of his room and thinks that she is making his situation even worse just so she can perform "great feats on his behalf." He also makes a snarky comment when she comes into his room and is looking around and Gregor remarks that he had to be somewhere. I think that the longer Gregor is trapped in his room, the more he is starting to get fed up with all of his family members.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Gregor's treatment of his sister definitely changes after she and his mother try to remove the furniture from his room. Before this scene Gregor seems very grateful of his sister's efforts and praises everything she does. This praise backs up the idea that he is accepting of his situation. After the incident with the furniture, Gregor seems much more critical of his sister and implies that she may not have been thinking as much about him as about her own interest in having this role in the household.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Gregor's relationship with his sister is interesting and changes significantly throughout the book. Gregor adores Grete throughout the book although he gradually gets more and more fed up with her attempts to care for him. However, although Grete was at first the person who cared the most about Gregor she is the one who eventually decides that the insect is no longer Gregor at all and effectively sends him to his death.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree that Gregor is likely not being sarcastic when he lists off reasons for his family not being able to work. The way I interpreted it, he couldn't be sarcastic, because, if we interpret his turning into an insect as him being an unquestioningly studious worker, he would have no reason for assuming that his family should bear part of his burden, because that's just not what insects do.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Nice interpretations! While Gregor was fulfilling his duty taking care of the family and working to pay off the family debt, his heart appears to long for freedom and better times. Even before his transformation into an insect, he knew that his parents were capable of doing more than they let on; and their subsequent unfair treatment of him only helps solidify his views. But the guilt he still feels for being a burden makes me also conclude that he is not speaking sarcastically but rather matter-of-factly.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I agree that Gregor is not being sarcastic when he gives us reasons why they do not work. I think that Gregor has a mindset in which he believes that no one around his is at fault. Instead, He is the one that causes things to happen. He probably thinks that since his family cannot work, he should work twice as hard to compensate for them. It wouldn't be in Gregor's character to be sarcastic when he lists off those reasons

    ReplyDelete